
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club
Best for culture + golf — choose The Vinoy if you want downtown St. Petersburg museums, marina access, championship golf and multiple on-site dining options.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club is a landmark 1925 waterfront resort in downtown St. Petersburg offering historic rooms, multiple restaurants, two heated pools and an on-site marina—good for travelers who want city attractions, museums and golf near the bay. Waterline Villas & Marina, Autograph Collection is an upscale marina-front villa property on Anna Maria Island that suits boating-focused stays and guests who want villa-style accommodations steps from island beaches.
Updated · about 35–45 miles apart (St. Petersburg ⇄ Holmes Beach by road)

Best for culture + golf — choose The Vinoy if you want downtown St. Petersburg museums, marina access, championship golf and multiple on-site dining options.

Best for island boating & villa stays — Waterline is ideal for guests seeking spacious 2-bedroom villas, a private dock/marina and quick access to Anna Maria Island beaches.
When The Vinoy wins: pick The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club if you prioritize a historic downtown address, more on-site restaurants and bars, larger event space, tennis and easy access to museums, the St. Pete Pier and a nearby 18-hole championship golf club.
When Waterline wins: pick Waterline Villas & Marina, Autograph Collection if you want villa-style accommodations with kitchens, direct marina access and an island-location that puts Bradenton and Anna Maria beaches within minutes.
Bottom line: both properties offer waterfront stays and marina facilities, but The Vinoy is the fuller resort experience in a walkable city setting with more venues and activities; Waterline is a smaller, villa-focused Autograph Collection option for guests prioritizing boating, kitchens and proximity to island beaches.
| Category | The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club | Waterline Villas & Marina, Autograph Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Landmark historic resort with formal and casual venues, active events calendar | Upscale, small-scale villa resort centered on marina access and island leisure |
| Location | Downtown St. Petersburg waterfront—museums, Pier and parks within easy walking distance | Holmes Beach on Anna Maria Island—close to Bradenton Beach and island beaches |
| Size (rooms) | About 354 rooms and suites across historic building + tower | 37 individually furnished guestrooms (villas) |
| Ages / family policy | All ages; family-friendly amenities (children's pool, kids' program) | All ages; not adults-only |
| Pools & water access | Two heated outdoor pools plus a children's pool; marina and Vinoy Yacht Basin nearby | One outdoor pool; private dock/marina and walkway to water |
| Restaurants & bars | Seven dining concepts (Elliott Aster signature, Paul's Landing, Parasol, Veranda, Lottie, Vinoy Club Grill, Clark’s Snack Bar) | The Chateau Anna Maria (American) + room service; a single on-site restaurant and one bar/lounge |
| Spa & wellness | Vinoy Spa with four treatment rooms, wet facilities and signature treatments; 24-hour fitness center and classes | Health or beauty spa nearby; 24-hour fitness facilities listed on property amenities |
| Known for | Historic 1925 property, downtown access, large event/wedding spaces and championship golf access | Villa-style two-bedroom guestrooms with kitchens and direct marina/boat access |
| Accessibility & family services | Accessible rooms, pool lift, roll-in showers, family services and kid-friendly dining | Multiple accessibility features (elevators, wide doors, wheelchair-accessible pool and restaurant); housekeeping on request |
| Parking & transit | Valet-only parking (fee) and good walkability; Cross-Bay Ferry nearby and public transit links | Self parking (surcharge) available onsite; island location often easiest with a car |
The Vinoy sits on the downtown St. Petersburg waterfront within walking distance of major museums, the St. Pete Pier and Vinoy Park.
Choose The Vinoy for a city-stay with waterfront views and museum/restaurant walking access.
Waterline is on Marina Drive in Holmes Beach, placing guests on Anna Maria Island close to beaches and island activities.
Choose Waterline if your priority is island beaches and being based on a small marina rather than in a downtown.
The Vinoy offers a large mix of historic rooms and modern tower suites across roughly 354 accommodations.
The Vinoy fits a wide range of party sizes and preferences, from single travelers to families needing multiple-room options.
Waterline's inventory emphasizes two-bedroom villa configurations, each furnished for longer-stay comfort.
Waterline is better suited to families or groups who want villa space and kitchen facilities for self-catering.
The Vinoy runs multiple on-site concepts from a Michelin-recommended signature restaurant to casual poolside dining.
The Vinoy is the pick for travelers who want several on-site dining styles and late-evening lounge options.
Waterline offers on-site American dining at The Chateau Anna Maria and room service, with fewer on-property outlets.
Waterline suits guests who plan to cook in their villa or visit island restaurants rather than rely on multiple on-site venues.
The Vinoy combines two heated outdoor pools and a marina with on-site watercraft rentals and easy access to the Cross-Bay Ferry.
Pick The Vinoy for multiple resort pools, marina views and integrated golf/tennis options.
Waterline centers on villa living and marina access, with one outdoor pool and an on-site dock for boats and personal watercraft.
Waterline is the better choice when marina/dock access and villa living are the main priorities.
The Vinoy has a full-service Vinoy Spa plus a 24-hour fitness center and a scattered nightlife scene across its bars and occasional live music.
The Vinoy offers more in-house wellness services and evening venues than Waterline.
Waterline provides fitness facilities and lists a nearby or on-site spa option; nightlife is low-key and island-focused.
Choose Waterline for island calm and basic fitness needs; choose Vinoy for a fuller spa and more evening options.

The Vinoy — walkable to the Dali Museum, Museum of Fine Arts, St. Pete Pier and downtown attractions.

Waterline — two-bedroom villas with full kitchens and sofa beds make longer stays and self-catering easy.

The Vinoy — seven dining concepts from a Michelin-recommended restaurant to poolside service.

Waterline — private dock/marina, personal watercraft listed on site and immediate island beach access.
Waterline Villas & Marina is on Anna Maria Island and a short drive to Bradenton Beach and nearby island beaches; The Vinoy is downtown St. Pete and requires a drive (about 20 minutes) to reach Gulf-front beaches.
Yes. The Vinoy is explicitly family-friendly with a children's pool and kids' programming; Waterline's two-bedroom villas with kitchens also suit families who prefer self-catering.
The Vinoy — it lists seven distinct dining concepts including the signature Elliott Aster and multiple casual options; Waterline has one primary on-site restaurant (The Chateau Anna Maria) and room service.
Yes. Both properties list marina/dock access; Waterline is a marina resort with an on-site dock and personal watercraft, while The Vinoy adjoins the Vinoy Yacht Basin and offers watercraft rentals and ferry access.
Explore how The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·