
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club
Best for guests who want resort services, on-site dining and a full spa/fitness/activities program in a landmark setting.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club is a landmark, full-service waterfront resort in downtown St. Petersburg with multiple restaurants, two heated pools, a spa and event spaces — good for travelers who want resort amenities and a historic setting. Sunshine Lane by Distinctive Beach Rentals is a professionally managed 3.5-star, 3‑bedroom vacation home on Treasure Island — a straightforward beach-rental option for small groups or families who want immediate beach access and a rental-style stay.
Updated · about 10 mi (16.1 km) apart

Best for guests who want resort services, on-site dining and a full spa/fitness/activities program in a landmark setting.

Best for travelers who want a professionally managed rental steps from the Gulf beach and nearby John's Pass for a small-group stay.
When The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club wins: choose the Vinoy if you want on-site restaurants (including a Michelin-recommended signature), multiple pools, a staffed front desk/concierge, a spa and extensive event or golf options — all in a historic downtown waterfront location.
When Sunshine Lane wins: pick Sunshine Lane if your priority is being steps from St. Pete–Clearwater beaches and John's Pass in a private, professionally managed 3‑bedroom house where rental-style convenience and beachfront access matter more than resort services.
Bottom line: both are solid beach-minded choices but for different needs — Vinoy is a full-service resort experience with food, spa and pools; Sunshine Lane is a no-frills, beach-forward rental for groups wanting immediate sand access.
| Category | The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club | Sunshine Lane by Distinctive Beach Rentals |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, full-service waterfront resort with formal and casual outlets | Professionally managed beach rental house focused on beach access |
| Location | Downtown St. Petersburg waterfront, marina and easy access to museums and the pier | Treasure Island — steps from St. Pete–Clearwater beaches and close to John's Pass |
| Size | Large resort: ~354 rooms and suites across historic building and tower | Single vacation home: House (3 Bedrooms) |
| Ages | All-ages, family-friendly (children’s pool, kids’ programs) | All-ages; not adults-only |
| Pools/beach | Two heated outdoor pools and a children’s pool | Beachfront / steps to sand (on-site pools: Not published) |
| Restaurants & bars | Seven on-site concepts including Elliott Aster (signature), Paul's Landing and poolside Parasol | No on-site restaurants listed; self-catering/nearby dining at John's Pass |
| Spa & fitness | Vinoy Spa with treatment rooms, whirlpool/sauna/steam and 24-hour fitness center | Spa services: Not published |
| Parking | Valet-only parking (fee, EV charging available) | Limited on-site parking |
| Accessibility & front desk | 24/7 staffed front desk, accessible rooms and pool hoist | No front desk; self check-in with access code; some upper floors accessed by stairs |
| Known for | Historic 1925 landmark on the St. Petersburg waterfront with marina and event spaces | Steps from St. Petersburg–Clearwater beaches and 0.6 mi from John's Pass Village & Boardwalk |
The Vinoy sits on the downtown St. Petersburg waterfront with easy walks to museums, the pier and parks.
Choose the Vinoy for a central, cultural waterfront base with marina access and short walks to downtown sites.
Sunshine Lane is located on Treasure Island with immediate access to Gulf beaches and close proximity to John's Pass.
Pick Sunshine Lane if your priority is being on the Gulf shoreline with easy beach and Johns Pass access.
The Vinoy offers a broad set of room types across historic and tower buildings to suit singles, couples and families.
The Vinoy suits travelers who want hotel conveniences and a variety of room styles and sizes.
Sunshine Lane is listed as a single House (3 Bedrooms) rental, individually decorated and intended for small groups.
Sunshine Lane is a simple three-bedroom home for groups that want a private rental footprint rather than hotel rooms.
The Vinoy has multiple on-site dining concepts from casual to fine dining, plus in-room dining.
If on-site meal variety and a signature dining experience matter, The Vinoy provides more choices.
Sunshine Lane does not list on-site restaurants; guests rely on nearby John's Pass and local eateries.
Sunshine Lane works if you plan to cook or dine out locally rather than expect hotel restaurants.
The Vinoy centers on two heated outdoor pools, marina access and a nearby 18‑hole golf club.
The Vinoy blends pool time with marina activities and golf — good for mixed water-and-land stays.
Sunshine Lane’s main draw in the listing is direct proximity to the Gulf beach rather than on-site pools or resort amenities.
Sunshine Lane’s advantage is immediate beach access and water activities; it’s a rental-first property rather than a resort with pools and a spa.
The Vinoy supports spa services, fitness classes, tennis and large event spaces alongside evening dining options.
The Vinoy is better suited for guests who want on-site wellness, sports and organized events or nightlife at hotel venues.
Sunshine Lane provides proximity to local attractions rather than on-property wellness or nightlife programming.
Choose Sunshine Lane for direct beach recreation and walking access to local shops and nightlife rather than hotel-led wellness or events.

The Vinoy — multiple on-site venues including Elliott Aster and poolside Parasol.

Sunshine Lane — steps from St. Pete–Clearwater Beaches and minutes on foot to John’s Pass.

The Vinoy — Vinoy Spa, 24‑hour fitness center, tennis courts and access to an 18‑hole golf club.

Sunshine Lane — a single 3‑bedroom house with private balcony and washer/dryer.
The Vinoy is downtown in St. Petersburg within easy walking distance of museums and the St. Pete Pier; Sunshine Lane is on Treasure Island and requires a drive or rideshare to reach downtown St. Pete.
No — Sunshine Lane uses self check-in with an access code and there is no staffed front desk listed; The Vinoy has 24/7 front-desk service.
The Vinoy is explicitly family-friendly with a children’s pool and kid-focused programming; Sunshine Lane is a 3‑bedroom rental that can work for families but lacks hotel childcare or kids’ facilities in the supplier listing.
No on-site restaurants are listed for Sunshine Lane — nearby dining is available at John’s Pass and other Treasure Island spots.
Explore how The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·