
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club
Best for families, golfers, and travelers who want a historic waterfront resort with multiple pools and on-site golf access.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club is a landmark 1925 waterfront resort in downtown St. Petersburg with a historic-household vibe and family-friendly amenities; read this if you want classic Bay-area resort living, golf, and easy access to St. Pete museums and the pier. The Tampa EDITION is a downtown Tampa, polished 5-star lifestyle hotel for travelers who prefer contemporary design, restaurants, and a central convention/riverwalk location.
Updated

Best for families, golfers, and travelers who want a historic waterfront resort with multiple pools and on-site golf access.

Best for visitors who want a centrally located, design-forward downtown stay with multiple bars/lounges and easy access to Tampa Riverwalk and the Convention Center.
When The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club wins: choose the Vinoy if you want a landmark 1925 resort experience, waterfront marina and bay views, on-site golf access, multiple distinct dining venues including a Michelin-recommended fine-dining option, and family-friendly pool options.
When The Tampa EDITION wins: choose the EDITION for a more compact, contemporary downtown stay with a full-service spa, multiple bars/lounges, a single outdoor pool with cabanas, and immediate walking access to Tampa Riverwalk, the Florida Aquarium and the convention district.
Bottom line: both are upscale choices but they serve different moods — pick The Vinoy for historic resort scale, family amenities and golf; pick The Tampa EDITION for a polished downtown lifestyle hotel and proximity to Tampa’s entertainment and convention hubs.
| Category | The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club | The Tampa EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic resort-social property with classic public rooms and a large event footprint | Polished, contemporary lifestyle hotel with downtown energy |
| Location | Downtown St. Petersburg waterfront, marina access and walkable to museums and the St. Pete Pier | Downtown Tampa, steps from Tampa Riverwalk, Benchmark Arena and the Convention Center |
| Size | About 354 rooms and suites across the historic building and a Deluxe Tower | 172 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / Audience | All-ages, family-friendly (kids' pool, kids programs) | All-ages (not adults-only); mainstream luxury lifestyle audience |
| Pools | Two heated outdoor pools plus a children's pool; poolside dining and cabana options | One outdoor pool with pool cabanas (surcharge) and one poolside bar |
| Restaurants & bars | Seven dining concepts including Elliott Aster (Michelin Recommended), Paul's Landing, Parasol and Veranda | Three restaurants, one coffee shop/cafe and four bars/lounges (including Mediterranean cuisine at Lilac) |
| Spa & fitness | Vinoy Spa with four treatment rooms, whirlpool, sauna and steam; 24-hour fitness center and complimentary classes | Full-service spa, 24-hour fitness center; spa treatments and wellness offerings available |
| Known for | Historic 1925 landmark, waterfront terraces, large event/wedding capacities and golf club access | Downtown lifestyle hotel with strong F&B program and proximity to Tampa Riverwalk and the arena |
| Accessibility & family services | Wheelchair-accessible public areas and rooms; family services and kids offerings | Wheelchair-accessible features throughout property; family-appropriate (not adults-only) |
| Parking & transport notes | Valet-only parking (approximate daily fee) and complimentary shuttle to Vinoy Golf Club; close to Cross-Bay Ferry | Valet parking (surcharge) and secured parking available; central walkable location for riverwalk and attractions |
The Vinoy sits on St. Petersburg’s downtown waterfront with marina access and short walks to museums and parks.
Choose the Vinoy for waterfront St. Pete access, cultural walking distances and easy bay crossings to Tampa.
The Tampa EDITION is located in Channelside, steps from the Riverwalk, the arena and the Tampa Convention Center.
Choose the EDITION if you want immediate access to Tampa’s downtown attractions and event venues.
The Vinoy offers a mix of historic rooms and modern tower rooms across roughly 354 accommodations.
The Vinoy is for travelers who want a choice between historic-period rooms and modern tower accommodations.
The Tampa EDITION has 172 individually decorated guestrooms and a selection of suites and penthouses.
The EDITION suits travelers who prefer contemporary, design-forward rooms in a downtown setting.
The Vinoy has seven distinct dining concepts covering fine dining, casual marina dining, poolside and a patisserie.
The Vinoy offers more venue variety for different meal moments, from pastry stops to fine dining.
The Tampa EDITION focuses on a smaller set of high-quality restaurants and multiple bars/lounges.
The EDITION concentrates on a polished F&B program tailored to a downtown crowd and late-night beverage options.
The Vinoy emphasizes resort-style waterfront recreation with two heated outdoor pools and a separate children's pool.
Pick the Vinoy if multiple pools, family swim options and marina activities matter to you.
The Tampa EDITION provides a single outdoor pool with cabanas (surcharge) and a poolside bar.
The EDITION’s pool is a downtown, lifestyle amenity rather than a multi-pool resort setup.
The Vinoy provides a dedicated spa, 24-hour fitness with classes, tennis courts and on-site golf connections.
The Vinoy is better for a full wellness and active-sports stay, including tennis and golf.
The Tampa EDITION offers a full-service spa and 24-hour fitness facilities and places you near downtown nightlife and event venues.
The EDITION is a strong pick for spa treatments and easy access to Tampa’s nighttime and event scene.

Two heated pools including a children’s pool, kids’ activities and family-focused dining options.

Walking distance to Tampa Convention Center, Benchmark Arena and Riverwalk; multiple bars/lounges onsite.

On-property tennis center and complimentary shuttle access to the 18-hole Vinoy Golf Club.

Design-forward rooms, concentrated F&B program and a streamlined urban location near major attractions.
The Vinoy — it advertises kids’ programs, a children’s pool and family-friendly dining; The Tampa EDITION is all-ages but oriented toward a downtown lifestyle.
The Tampa EDITION is steps from the Tampa Convention Center and Benchmark International Arena, making it the more convenient choice for events.
The Tampa EDITION listing does not show on‑site championship golf access; The Vinoy provides shuttle access to the Vinoy Golf Club and is the better option for golf.
Yes — both properties have full-service spas and 24-hour fitness facilities per their listings.
Explore how The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·