
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club
Best for travelers who want on-site dining variety, a full-service spa, pools and formal event spaces.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club is a landmark, full-service waterfront resort in downtown St. Petersburg for travelers who want hotels with multiple restaurants, a spa, pools and event space. Treasure Island Escape is a casual, beach-area apartment property in Treasure Island for people who want simple Gulf-front access and pet-friendly 1–2 bedroom units.
Updated · about 18 km apart

Best for travelers who want on-site dining variety, a full-service spa, pools and formal event spaces.

Best for travelers who want a straightforward beach-area apartment with a kitchen and pet-friendly room types close to John's Pass.
When The Vinoy wins: choose The Vinoy if you want an upscale downtown St. Petersburg base with multiple restaurants and bars, a named spa (Vinoy Spa), two heated outdoor pools and wide event/wedding facilities.
When Treasure Island Escape wins: choose Treasure Island Escape if you want a low-key, beach-area apartment in Treasure Island with kitchen-equipped 1- or 2-bedroom pet-friendly units and very close beach access at a Gulf Coast location.
Bottom line: The Vinoy is an amenity-rich resort suited to guests seeking full-service dining, wellness and waterfront-sightseeing in downtown St. Pete; Treasure Island Escape is a practical, casual option for Gulf-beach time and simple apartment-style stays.
| Category | The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club | Treasure Island Escape |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Upscale historic waterfront resort with formal dining and spa offerings. | Casual beach-area apartment property focused on simple stays and beach access. |
| Location | Downtown St. Petersburg, on the Tampa Bay waterfront near museums and the pier. | Treasure Island (Sunshine Beach) near John's Pass Village & Boardwalk and St. Petersburg - Clearwater Beaches. |
| Size | Large resort with about 354 rooms and extensive event space. | Small apartment property — room count not published. |
| Ages | All-ages, family-friendly (children's pool, kids' activities listed). | All-ages — not adults-only (listing: adultsOnly: false). |
| Pools / water access | Two heated outdoor pools and a children's pool (resort pools on-site). | Beachfront access to St. Petersburg - Clearwater Beaches; on-site pool information not published. |
| Restaurants & bars | Seven on-site concepts (Elliott Aster, Paul's Landing, Parasol, Veranda, Lottie, Vinoy Club Grill, Clark's Snack Bar). | No on-site full restaurants listed; apartment units have kitchens; closest dining at nearby John's Pass. |
| Spa & wellness | Vinoy Spa on-site with treatment rooms, whirlpool, sauna and steam; fitness center and classes. | Not published. |
| Known for | Historic 1925 landmark building, marina and proximity to downtown attractions. | Steps from the Gulf beaches and a short walk to John's Pass Village & Boardwalk. |
| Pet policy | Pets allowed (dogs only), up to two per room, fees and registration required. | Apartment room types explicitly list 'Pets Allowed'. |
| Check-in / Check-out | Standard check-in 4:00 PM; check-out 11:00 AM. | Check-in window listed as 4:00 PM–8:00 PM; check-out 10:00 AM. |
The Vinoy sits on downtown St. Petersburg’s Tampa Bay waterfront within walking distance of museums, the pier and Vinoy Park.
Choose The Vinoy for waterfront sightseeing and downtown walkability.
Treasure Island Escape is located on Treasure Island (Sunshine Beach), a short walk from the public Gulf beaches and John's Pass Village & Boardwalk.
Choose Treasure Island Escape for direct Gulf beach access and easy access to nearby beach-town dining and activities.
The Vinoy offers a wide range of historic rooms, tower rooms and suites across roughly 354 accommodations.
Choose The Vinoy for varied room types, historic character and larger-suite options.
Treasure Island Escape rents apartment-style units designed for short stays with kitchen facilities.
Choose Treasure Island Escape for self-catering 1–2 bedroom apartments and pet-friendly stays.
The Vinoy lists seven on-site dining concepts covering fine dining, casual seafood, poolside meals and a patisserie.
Choose The Vinoy for a wide range of on-site dining without leaving the property.
Treasure Island Escape does not list on-site full-service restaurants; units have kitchens for self-catering.
Choose Treasure Island Escape if you prefer self-catering or exploring local beach-town restaurants.
The Vinoy provides two heated outdoor pools and a children's pool as primary water recreation on site.
Choose The Vinoy for resort-style pool time plus marina and bay activities.
Treasure Island Escape is steps from the Gulf beaches; on-site pool information is not provided in the supplier listing.
Choose Treasure Island Escape if private beach access and Gulf sand/time on the shore are your priority.
The Vinoy includes a named Vinoy Spa, wet facilities and a 24-hour fitness center with complimentary classes.
Choose The Vinoy for on-site spa, fitness programming and evening dining/drink options.
Treasure Island Escape relies on nearby beach-town entertainment rather than on-site wellness facilities.
Choose Treasure Island Escape if you plan to spend days on the beach and evenings exploring local boards and bars.

The Vinoy — seven distinct on-site restaurants and bars, including a Michelin-Recommended signature restaurant.

Treasure Island Escape — steps from the public Gulf beaches and a short walk to John's Pass Village & Boardwalk.

The Vinoy — on-site Vinoy Spa, whirlpool/sauna/steam and a 24-hour fitness center with classes.

Treasure Island Escape — apartment units labeled 'Pets Allowed' with kitchens and laundry conveniences.
The Vinoy is marketed as family-friendly with a children's pool, kids' programming references and family dining options; Treasure Island Escape is an apartment property that can suit families who want a kitchen and beach time.
Yes — the supplier listing places the apartment steps from St. Petersburg - Clearwater Beaches and St. Petersburg Municipal Beach at Treasure Island.
Yes — The Vinoy lists seven on-site dining concepts (including Elliott Aster and Paul's Landing) and the Vinoy Spa with treatment rooms and wet facilities.
The Vinoy accepts dogs with limits and fees; Treasure Island Escape lists apartment room types as 'Pets Allowed'. Confirm pet rules and fees with each property before booking.
The Vinoy standard check-in is 4:00 PM and check-out 11:00 AM. Treasure Island Escape's listing shows check-in between 4:00 PM–8:00 PM and check-out at 10:00 AM.
Explore how The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·