
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club
Best for travelers who want multiple on-site restaurants, a full-service spa, pools and easy access to downtown St. Petersburg attractions and a marina.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club is an upscale, historic bayfront resort in downtown St. Petersburg for travelers who want full-service dining, spa, golf and marina access. The Marker is a budget-oriented, hotel-style option in Clearwater Beach for travelers who want simple rooms with kitchens and an outdoor pool near Clearwater Beach attractions.
Updated

Best for travelers who want multiple on-site restaurants, a full-service spa, pools and easy access to downtown St. Petersburg attractions and a marina.

Best for budget-minded visitors who want simple, apartment-style rooms (kitchenettes and private balconies) within short driving distance of Clearwater Beach.
When The Vinoy wins: Choose The Vinoy for a multi-venue dining program (including the Michelin-recommended Elliott Aster), a staffed full-service spa (Vinoy Spa), two heated outdoor pools, on-site tennis and access to an 18-hole championship golf club — plus waterfront/marina access and downtown St. Pete attractions within walking distance.
When The Marker wins: Choose The Marker if you need affordable, self-contained rooms with full-sized refrigerators, stovetops and private balconies, free self parking, and a simple outdoor pool close to Clearwater Beach activities without paying resort-level prices.
Bottom line: The Vinoy is a full-service, higher-end resort for guests prioritizing dining, spa, pools and golf in downtown St. Pete; The Marker is a no-frills, budget hotel-style option in the Clearwater Beach area for practical, lower-cost stays with kitchenette-style rooms.
| Category | The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club | The Marker |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, upscale full-service resort | Budget-oriented, hotel-style property |
| Location | Downtown St. Petersburg waterfront; marina and bay views | Clearwater Beach area (hotel is located in Clearwater Beach neighborhood; attractions a short drive away) |
| Size (rooms) | About 354 rooms and suites across historic building and tower | 60 guestrooms |
| Ages / family policy | All-ages, family-friendly (children’s pool, kids programs noted) | All-ages (not adults-only) |
| Pools | Two heated outdoor swimming pools plus a children’s pool | One outdoor pool with loungers |
| Restaurants & bars | Seven on-site concepts (Elliott Aster, Paul’s Landing, Parasol, Veranda, Lottie, Vinoy Club Grill, pool bar/snack options) | Not published on-site signature restaurants; listing highlights in-room kitchen facilities and nearby dining |
| Spa & wellness | Vinoy Spa with treatment rooms, whirlpool/sauna/steam and fitness center with classes | Not published |
| Known for | Historic 1925 waterfront landmark with marina, event space, golf and dining | Affordable, kitchen-equipped rooms and free self parking near Clearwater Beach attractions |
| Parking | Valet-only parking (fee; EV charging available) | Free self parking on site |
| Accessibility & front desk | 24/7 front desk; wheelchair-accessible rooms and pool lift | No front desk — property provides check-in instructions by email; wheelchair accessible – no (per listing) |
The Vinoy sits on downtown St. Petersburg’s waterfront with marina and Tampa Bay views and easy walking access to museums and the St. Pete Pier.
Best if you want downtown culture, marina access and short walks to museums and the pier.
The Marker is located in the Clearwater Beach area at 850 Bayway Blvd, positioned for short drives to Beach Walk, Pier 60 Park and other Clearwater attractions.
Best if you want a practical base for Clearwater Beach activities with short drives to the sand and pier.
The Vinoy offers a wide range of room and suite types across a historic building and a modern tower.
Best for travelers who want many room types and waterfront or tower-view upgrades.
The Marker’s accommodation is simpler and focused on self-contained units with kitchens and private balconies.
Best for stays where having a kitchenette and balcony is a priority at a lower price point.
The Vinoy has multiple on-site dining venues covering fine dining, casual marina views and poolside service.
Best for guests who want a wide choice of on-site restaurants and bars, including fine dining.
The Marker listing emphasizes in-room kitchenettes more than multiple on-site dining outlets.
Best for travelers who plan to self-cater or eat at nearby Clearwater Beach restaurants rather than rely on hotel dining.
Pools and marina life are central to The Vinoy’s resort experience.
Best for guests who want heated pools, poolside dining and easy access to boating.
The Marker offers a single outdoor pool and basic poolside lounging.
Best for travelers who need a simple pool to cool off and prefer beach access nearby by car.
The Vinoy provides a full spa, fitness center and a range of on-site activities and events.
Best for travelers looking for spa treatments, fitness classes, tennis and event-driven programming.
The Marker focuses on basic conveniences rather than full-service wellness or nightlife offerings.
Best for travelers who prioritize a practical room and short drives to local nightlife or wellness businesses.

The Vinoy — multiple on-site restaurants including Elliott Aster and marina-view dining make it superior for food-focused stays.

The Marker — kitchen-equipped rooms and free self parking provide value for longer or self-catered stays.

The Vinoy — a full-service Vinoy Spa, 24-hour fitness center with classes, and a tennis center give more wellness and activity options.

The Marker — located in the Clearwater Beach area for short drives to Pier 60, Beach Walk and Sand Key Park.
The Marker is located in the Clearwater Beach area and is the more convenient base for Pier 60 and Clearwater Beach; The Vinoy is on downtown St. Petersburg’s waterfront and requires a drive to reach Clearwater Beach.
Yes — The Marker’s rooms include full-sized refrigerators/freezers and stovetops, plus microwaves and separate sitting areas.
The Vinoy has the Vinoy Spa with treatment rooms and wet facilities; The Marker’s supplier listing does not publish a spa.
Yes. The Vinoy is marketed as family-friendly with a children’s pool, kids’ programs and family-room options.
Explore how The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·