
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club
Best for travelers who want a full-service, historic resort with multiple on-site restaurants, a dedicated spa, tennis and golf access.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club is a landmark, full-service waterfront resort in downtown St. Petersburg for travelers who want polished historic rooms, multiple restaurants, a spa and resort recreation. Cedar Cove Resort and Cottages is a casual beach-resort and cottage property on Anna Maria Island for guests who prioritize sand, simple kitchens and a strong beachside vibe.
Updated · about 35 km apart

Best for travelers who want a full-service, historic resort with multiple on-site restaurants, a dedicated spa, tennis and golf access.

Best for guests who want direct beach access, cottage-style rooms with kitchens and a small, relaxed Anna Maria Island location.
When The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club wins: Choose The Vinoy if you want a large, full-service resort experience — signature fine dining (Elliott Aster), Vinoy Spa, two heated outdoor pools, tennis, organized fitness classes and easy access to downtown St. Petersburg attractions.
When Cedar Cove Resort and Cottages wins: Pick Cedar Cove if your trip is primarily about beach time on Anna Maria Island, staying in individually decorated cottages or suites with kitchen facilities and a compact property that puts sand and local beach businesses within walking distance.
Bottom line: The Vinoy is for guests seeking resort amenities, dining variety and a historic waterfront address; Cedar Cove is for travelers prioritizing a simpler, beach-cottage stay and direct island access.
| Category | The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club | Cedar Cove Resort and Cottages |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Formal/historic full-service resort with resort programming and event spaces | Casual beach cottages and small resort-style property |
| Location | Downtown St. Petersburg waterfront, walkable to museums and the pier | Holmes Beach on Anna Maria Island, a short walk to Bradenton/Coquina beaches |
| Size (rooms) | About 354 rooms and suites across a historic building and a tower | 19 individually decorated guestrooms and cottages |
| Ages / policy | All-ages, family-friendly (kids’ programs, children’s pool); minimum check-in age listed as 21 on some sources | All-ages, family-friendly |
| Pools | Two heated outdoor pools plus a children’s pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Seven dining concepts including Elliott Aster (signature), Paul's Landing, Parasol, Veranda and Lottie | Not published as multiple signature restaurants; property has on-site kitchens in many units and nearby island dining |
| Spa & wellness | Vinoy Spa with treatment rooms, whirlpool, sauna and steam; 24-hour fitness center and classes | Not published (free use of nearby fitness center is offered) |
| Known for | Historic 1925 waterfront landmark, marina access, golf and large event space | Beach-cottage format, kitchens in rooms, strong traveler rating for simple beach stays |
| Beach access | Beach access by car (St. Pete Beach about 20 minutes); not a beachfront property | Beachfront property on Anna Maria Island |
| On-site parking | Valet-only parking (fee, EV chargers available) | Free self parking on site |
The Vinoy sits on St. Petersburg’s downtown waterfront within walking distance of major museums and the pier.
Choose The Vinoy for city-access to attractions and a marina-front address.
Cedar Cove is centrally located in Holmes Beach on Anna Maria Island, a short walk from Bradenton Beach and island shops.
Choose Cedar Cove if being steps from beach and island life matters most.
The Vinoy offers a wide range of historic rooms and modern tower suites with traditional resort amenities.
The Vinoy has options for families, couples and larger suites with resort-level finishes.
Cedar Cove provides 19 individually decorated guestrooms and cottages, many with kitchens.
Cedar Cove suits travelers who want cottage-style rooms and in-room kitchens for casual stays.
The Vinoy has multiple on-site dining concepts from fine dining to poolside cafes.
Expect a full range of on-site dining options at different price points and styles.
Cedar Cove emphasizes cottage stays with kitchens; on-site dining concepts are not published.
Cedar Cove is better for self-catering or exploring local island restaurants.
The Vinoy offers two heated outdoor pools, a children’s pool and poolside dining.
Choose The Vinoy for resort pool time plus marina and bay activities.
Cedar Cove is a beach resort with direct access to Anna Maria Island’s beaches.
Cedar Cove is for guests who want to prioritize beach time rather than resort pools.
The Vinoy provides a full spa, 24-hour fitness center with classes and easy access to downtown nightlife.
The Vinoy is best for travelers who want on-site wellness and downtown evening options.
Cedar Cove focuses on beach activities, island calm and nearby casual nightlife.
Cedar Cove suits low-key island evenings and outdoor beach-focused activities.

Elliott Aster and multiple on-site restaurants give The Vinoy a clear edge for food-focused stays.

Cedar Cove's beachfront cottages and island location make it the easier pick for days spent on sand.

Vinoy Spa, fitness classes and full-service wellness facilities make The Vinoy better for spa-focused travelers.

Many Cedar Cove units include full kitchens and larger-suite options suited to self-catering stays.
The Vinoy is downtown St. Petersburg and within easy walking distance of museums, the pier and Vinoy Park; Cedar Cove is on Anna Maria Island and requires a drive or ferry to reach downtown St. Pete.
The Vinoy is explicitly family-friendly with kids’ amenities, children’s pool and family programming; Cedar Cove is family-friendly too but is smaller and more beach-focused.
Cedar Cove commonly lists kitchens or full refrigerators/ovens in many units; The Vinoy offers in-room dining but not full kitchens in standard guest rooms.
Cedar Cove is beachfront on Anna Maria Island; The Vinoy is on the downtown waterfront with a marina but is not a Gulf-front beachfront hotel.
Explore how The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·