
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club
Best for travelers who want a historic, full-service waterfront resort with golf, multiple dining venues, and extensive event spaces.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club is a landmark 1925 bayfront resort in downtown St. Petersburg with golf, multiple restaurants, two heated pools and a full spa. Anna Maria Beach Resort is a smaller beachfront resort-style hotel on Anna Maria Island for travelers who want direct Gulf access and a low-key island stay.
Updated

Best for travelers who want a historic, full-service waterfront resort with golf, multiple dining venues, and extensive event spaces.

Best for travelers who prioritize direct beach access, a compact island property, and simple beachfront amenities.
When The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club wins: Choose The Vinoy if you want a larger, full-service resort experience — multiple signature restaurants (including Elliott Aster), a dedicated spa (Vinoy Spa), two heated outdoor pools, on-site tennis and easy access to downtown St. Petersburg attractions and a nearby 18-hole championship golf course.
When Anna Maria Beach Resort wins: Choose Anna Maria Beach Resort if your main priority is being on the sand on Anna Maria Island, a smaller property footprint, simpler on-site amenities, and fewer crowds than a downtown resort.
Bottom line: Pick The Vinoy for bayfront variety, dining and resort facilities; pick Anna Maria Beach Resort for a straightforward beachfront stay on Anna Maria Island.
| Category | The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club | Anna Maria Beach Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, full-service waterfront resort with formal and casual dining, event spaces and marina access. | Small, beachfront resort-style hotel focused on beach access and relaxed island stays. |
| Location | Downtown St. Petersburg waterfront, steps from museums, parks and the marina (Tampa Bay views). | Holmes Beach on Anna Maria Island with private beach access and short drives to island attractions. |
| Size | Large — about 354 rooms and suites across historic building and Deluxe Tower. | Small — 31 rooms. |
| Ages | All ages (family-friendly; children’s pool, kids’ activities listed). | |
| Pools & water | Two heated outdoor pools (plus children’s pool) and marina/bay access; poolside dining and cabana options. | One outdoor pool and a private beach; hot tub reported onsite. |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple concepts (Elliott Aster fine dining, Paul’s Landing, Parasol poolside, Veranda, Lottie patisserie, Vinoy Club Grill). | No signature full-service restaurant listed; smaller on-site dining options and poolside service are available. |
| Spa & wellness | Vinoy Spa with four treatment rooms, wet facilities and a menu of signature treatments; 24-hour fitness center and classes. | Not published |
| Known for | Historic 1925 landmark, event and wedding venues, marina and golf club shuttle access. | Direct beachfront location on Anna Maria Island and intimate island setting. |
| Parking & front desk | Valet-only parking (fee); 24/7 front desk service. | Free self parking onsite (limited spaces); front desk staffed during limited hours. |
| Room features | Wide range of room types and suites (15 types listed) across historic and tower buildings. | 31 air-conditioned rooms with refrigerators and microwaves; room types include Oceanfront Pool View and 1-Bedroom Suites. |
The Vinoy sits on downtown St. Petersburg’s waterfront with immediate access to the marina, parks and museums.
Choose The Vinoy for a culturally focused waterfront stay with city attractions within walking distance.
Anna Maria Beach Resort is located on Holmes Beach with direct private beach access on Anna Maria Island.
Choose Anna Maria Beach Resort if you want to be steps from the sand and prefer island pace over city access.
The Vinoy offers a broad mix of historic rooms and modern tower suites across many room categories.
The Vinoy suits travelers who want choices in room type, views (bay/resort), and upscale suite options.
Anna Maria Beach Resort is a much smaller property with a limited set of oceanfront and suite choices.
Anna Maria Beach Resort works well for travelers wanting compact, beach-facing room options without a large hotel footprint.
The Vinoy provides multiple on-site dining concepts from fine dining to casual poolside options.
Pick The Vinoy when you want variety in meal style and a notable signature restaurant.
Anna Maria Beach Resort has more limited on-site food and beverage offerings compared with a large resort.
Anna Maria Beach Resort is best when you plan to sample island restaurants or prefer simple on-site options.
The Vinoy has two heated outdoor pools and direct marina/bay access but is not beachfront on the Gulf.
The Vinoy is better if you want multiple resort pools and marina activities rather than Gulf beachfront.
Anna Maria Beach Resort centers on direct beach access with one outdoor pool and an on-site hot tub.
Anna Maria Beach Resort is the straightforward choice for guests whose priority is stepping onto the sand.
The Vinoy includes a full-service spa, fitness center and on-site activities plus nearby nightlife options in downtown St. Pete.
Choose The Vinoy for an on-property spa, fitness options and easy access to downtown evening activities.
Anna Maria Beach Resort offers a low-key island atmosphere rather than an extensive wellness or nightlife program.
Anna Maria Beach Resort is better when you want quiet beach days and local island evenings rather than resort spa programming.

The Vinoy — multiple dining concepts including Elliott Aster fine dining.

Anna Maria Beach Resort — private beach and immediate Gulf access on Anna Maria Island.

The Vinoy — extensive event space options and multiple outdoor ceremony lawns.

Anna Maria Beach Resort — compact property with beachfront rooms and island proximity.
The Vinoy is more family-oriented with two heated pools, a children’s pool and kids’ programming; Anna Maria Beach Resort is family-friendly but is a smaller beachfront property with limited on-site activities.
Anna Maria Beach Resort has private beach access on Anna Maria Island; The Vinoy is bayfront with marina access but requires a short drive to Gulf beaches.
The Vinoy has a full-service Vinoy Spa with treatment rooms and wet facilities. Anna Maria Beach Resort does not list a multi-treatment spa in the supplier facts (Not published).
The Vinoy — several on-site restaurants and bars cover fine dining, breakfast, poolside meals and a patisserie; Anna Maria Beach Resort has simpler on-site dining and easy access to island restaurants.
Explore how The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·